Shop Blanton's & Buffalo Trace Distillery Bottles →
If you're searching for Buffalo Trace bourbon online, you're not alone and if you're worried about getting scammed, that concern is completely valid.
From Blanton's to Double Eagle Very Rare, demand for Buffalo Trace Distillery's most sought-after releases has exploded. Unfortunately, so have fraudulent websites. Buffalo Trace Distillery has publicly warned consumers about a rising number of scam sites selling counterfeit or nonexistent bottles.
This guide tells you exactly what to watch for and how to buy with confidence from a retailer you can trust.
Ready to buy? LoveScotch is a licensed, BBB Accredited retailer with verified inventory.
Shop Blanton's → Shop Buffalo Trace →Buffalo Trace Has Issued Public Scam Warnings
Buffalo Trace Distillery has confirmed that multiple fraudulent websites are actively targeting high-demand bottles, including:
Consumers have reported:
- Paying for bottles that never arrived
- Receiving empty bottles
- Receiving counterfeit bottles with plastic toppers instead of authentic metal ones
The distillery has taken legal action against some sites, but the problem persists, especially across social media ads and overseas-operated websites.
Why Are Buffalo Trace Bottles Targeted?
Buffalo Trace is a National Historic Landmark and has won more than 1,000 awards. Its allocated releases, Blanton's, Eagle Rare, George T. Stagg, Weller, are among the most collectible American whiskeys in the world. Because supply is strictly limited and global demand is through the roof, scarcity creates the perfect environment for counterfeit sellers to exploit buyers looking for a deal.
Red Flags When Buying Bourbon Online
If you're comparing retailers, these are the warning signs that should make you walk away:
| Red Flag | What It Usually Means |
|---|---|
| Price dramatically below market value | Almost always a scam signal. Scarce bourbon is not cheap. |
| "Ships anywhere in the U.S." with no restrictions | Alcohol shipping is state-regulated. Legitimate retailers comply. |
| Overseas website location | Buffalo Trace's legal team has confirmed many scam sites operate overseas. |
| No BBB accreditation or verifiable business registration | No accountability if something goes wrong. |
| Stock images instead of real bottle photography | Real retailers photograph their own inventory. |
How to Verify a Legitimate Bourbon Retailer
Use this checklist before any high-value purchase:
| Verification Point | What to Look For | LoveScotch |
|---|---|---|
| Business registration | Registered U.S. company | ✅ |
| Secure checkout (HTTPS) | Encrypted payment processing | ✅ |
| Market-aligned pricing | Reflects real scarcity, no suspicious discounts | ✅ |
| Clear, compliant shipping policies | States which states they ship to, no "ships everywhere" claims | ✅ |
| BBB Accreditation | Independent third-party business verification | ✅ |
| Licensed distribution sourcing | Bottles come through official channels, not gray market | ✅ |
LoveScotch.com checks every box. We are a BBB Accredited, U.S.-registered retailer sourcing all inventory through licensed distribution channels. Every bottle is authentic and verified before it ships.
Shop Buffalo Trace Distillery Bottles at LoveScotch
Verified authentic. Licensed sourcing. Secure checkout. Ships fast from Southern California.
Blanton's Single Barrel Bourbon, The World's First Single Barrel
The bottle that started the single barrel category. Blanton's is one of the most hunted bourbons in the world and one of the most faked. When you buy from LoveScotch, you're getting an authentic, sealed bottle sourced through licensed U.S. distribution. Real metal horse-and-jockey stopper. Real Blanton's.
Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon, The Flagship
The bottle that put Buffalo Trace on the map. Caramel, vanilla, warm spice, approachable and consistently excellent. One of the most award-winning bourbons in history at one of the most accessible price points. Verified authentic, in stock, and ships fast.
Eagle Rare, The Step Up
10-year-aged single barrel bourbon from Buffalo Trace. Complex, bold, and impossible to find at most retail stores. Eagle Rare's allocation is just as tight as Blanton's, which makes it just as much of a target for scam sites. Buy it here: verified, licensed, authenticated.
The Full Buffalo Trace Family, All Verified, All In Stock
Weller · E.H. Taylor · George T. Stagg · Sazerac Rye · and more, all sourced through licensed U.S. distribution. If it's on LoveScotch, it's real.
What's the Real Price of Blanton's and Buffalo Trace?
This is one of the most searched questions in bourbon and it matters for spotting scams.
Rule of thumb: If you see Blanton's listed at $50-60, or Eagle Rare at $30, question it immediately. These bottles trade at a significant premium over MSRP because demand far exceeds supply. "Cheap" allocated bourbon is one of the clearest scam signals in the market.
LoveScotch prices reflect real market availability, honest, transparent, and in line with what these bottles actually cost when you can find them. We'd rather lose a sale than mislead a buyer.
Is It Legal to Buy Buffalo Trace Online?
It depends on your state. In most U.S. states, direct-to-consumer alcohol shipping is regulated, not banned, but restricted. Legitimate retailers clearly state which states they ship to and comply with applicable laws.
Before purchasing:
- Confirm your state allows shipment from licensed out-of-state retailers
- Verify the retailer's license and business registration
- Avoid any site claiming to ship "anywhere in the U.S. with no restrictions", that's a red flag
What to Do If You've Been Scammed
If you've already purchased from a site that turned out to be fraudulent, act immediately:
- Report the site to the Better Business Bureau at bbb.org
- Contact your State Attorney General, counterfeit alcohol sales are a criminal matter
- Call your credit card company immediately to dispute the charge and initiate fraud protection
- Report to Buffalo Trace Distillery directly, they have a legal team actively pursuing fraudulent sellers
The sale of counterfeit alcohol is not just a financial scam, it's a safety issue. Counterfeit spirits can contain harmful substances. Take it seriously.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is LoveScotch a legitimate place to buy Blanton's and Buffalo Trace?
Yes. LoveScotch.com is a BBB Accredited, U.S.-licensed retailer that sources all inventory through official distribution channels. We have real customer support, encrypted checkout, and transparent policies. Every Blanton's bottle we ship has the authentic metal horse-and-jockey topper, not plastic.
Why is Blanton's so hard to find?
Buffalo Trace Distillery strictly controls Blanton's production and allocation. Demand has grown dramatically over the past decade while supply has remained limited by design. Most retail stores sell out within hours or days of receiving an allocation, which is why secondary market prices are high and scam sites prey on buyers looking for a deal.
Is the price of Blanton's on LoveScotch above MSRP?
Possibly, yes and that's honest. Blanton's allocated MSRP is approximately $65, but the actual market rate (what bottles sell for when you can find them) is significantly higher. We price to reflect real market availability, not fictional MSRP. A site selling Blanton's at $65 in 2024 should raise questions, not excitement.
How do I know the bottle is authentic?
LoveScotch sources all inventory through licensed U.S. distribution channels, not gray market importers or secondary resellers. Every bottle is verified before it ships. Authentic Blanton's has a real metal stopper with a horse and jockey figurine, proper labeling, and intact wax seal. If a bottle arrives with a plastic topper or suspicious packaging, contact us immediately.
What states does LoveScotch ship to?
LoveScotch ships to most U.S. states in compliance with applicable alcohol shipping laws. Check our current shipping policy page for up-to-date state eligibility. We do not claim to ship everywhere, that would be both dishonest and illegal.
Buy Blanton's & Buffalo Trace With Confidence
BBB Accredited · Licensed U.S. retailer · Verified authentic inventory · Secure checkout · Ships fast from Southern California
Rare bourbon should be exciting, not risky. This is how you do it right.
Shop Blanton's → Shop Buffalo Trace → Shop Eagle Rare →
