If you’re searching for Buffalo Trace bourbon online, you’re not alone.
From Blanton’s to Double Eagle Very Rare, demand for Buffalo Trace Distillery’s most sought-after releases has exploded. Unfortunately, so have scams.
In fact, Buffalo Trace Distillery has publicly warned consumers about a rising number of fraudulent websites selling counterfeit or nonexistent bottles online.
- So how do you know where to buy safely?
- How do you verify pricing?
- And how can you tell if a retailer is legitimate?
This guide explains everything you need to know before purchasing Buffalo Trace products online and how to avoid becoming another victim.
Buffalo Trace Has Issued Public Scam Warnings
Buffalo Trace Distillery has confirmed that multiple fraudulent websites are targeting high-demand bottles like:
Consumers have reported:
- Paying for bottles that never arrived
- Receiving empty bottles
- Receiving counterfeit bottles with plastic toppers instead of authentic metal toppers
The distillery has taken legal action against some sites, but the problem persists — especially across social media ads and overseas-operated websites.
Why Are Buffalo Trace Bottles Targeted?
Buffalo Trace produces some of the most collectible American whiskeys in the world.
The distillery is a National Historic Landmark and has won more than 1,000 awards. Its legacy includes legendary figures like:
- E.H. Taylor Jr.
- George T. Stagg
- Albert B. Blanton
- Elmer T. Lee
Because allocation is limited and demand is global, bottles like Blanton’s frequently sell out at retail. That scarcity creates the perfect environment for counterfeit sellers to exploit buyers looking for a deal.
Red Flags When Buying Bourbon Online
If you’re comparing retailers, watch for these warning signs:
1. Prices That Seem Too Good to Be True
If a rare bottle is listed dramatically below market value, that’s typically a scam signal.
2. Shipping to States Where It’s Illegal
In most U.S. states, alcohol cannot be shipped directly to consumers. If a site promises shipping anywhere in the U.S. with no restrictions, proceed carefully.
3. Overseas Website Locations
Buffalo Trace’s legal counsel has noted that many scam sites are operated overseas.
Is It Legal to Buy Buffalo Trace Online?
This is one of the most common search questions.
The answer depends on your state’s alcohol shipping laws.
In most states, direct to consumer alcohol shipping is restricted. That’s why legitimate retailers clearly state shipping eligibility and comply with state regulations.
- Before purchasing:
- Confirm your state allows shipment
- Verify retailer licensing
Avoid sites claiming nationwide shipping without restrictions
How to Verify a Legitimate Bourbon Retailer
If you’re searching “Is this website legit?” here’s a quick checklist:
| Verification Point | What to Look For |
| Business Registration | Registered U.S. company |
| Secure Checkout | HTTPS encryption |
| Transparent Pricing | Market-aligned pricing |
| Clear Shipping Policies | State-compliant restrictions |
If something feels off, trust that instinct.
Buying Buffalo Trace, Blanton’s & Rare Bourbon Safely
At LoveScotch, we understand why buyers are cautious.
Rare bourbon purchases are high-intent, high-dollar decisions. That’s why we prioritize:
Transparent pricing
- Clear shipping compliance
- Secure checkout processing
- Established retail operations
- Authentic, sealed inventory
When comparing retailers, always look for operational legitimacy not just price.
Comparing Buffalo Trace Retailers: What Actually Matters?
When buyers compare:
- “Best price for Blanton’s online”
- “Where to buy Buffalo Trace bourbon”
- “Is [site name] legit?”
The decision usually comes down to three factors:
1. Trust
Is the retailer compliant, transparent, and established?
2. Authenticity
Are bottles sourced through proper distribution channels?
3. Pricing Reality
Does the price reflect real secondary market demand?
Scarce bourbon is rarely “cheap.” If it is, question it.
What To Do If You’ve Been Scammed
Buffalo Trace recommends:
- Reporting the site to the Better Business Bureau
- Contacting your State Attorney General
- Calling your credit card company for fraud protection
The sale of counterfeit alcohol is a global issue and can pose serious safety risks.
If you suspect fraud, act immediately.
Why Structured, Transparent Retail Matters
In today’s bourbon market, buyers aren’t just searching for bottles.
They’re searching for:
- Verification
- Legitimacy
- Fair pricing
- Compliance clarity
Every time someone asks:
- “Where can I safely buy Blanton’s?”
- “Is this Buffalo Trace website real?”
- “What’s the real price of Double Eagle Very Rare?”
- “Can Buffalo Trace ship to my state?”
They are in the decision stage.
That’s where reputable retailers like Lovescotch.com must show up clearly and transparently.
Final Thoughts: Buy Rare Bourbon With Confidence
Buffalo Trace Distillery has built a reputation over nearly 250 years. The demand for its whiskeys isn’t slowing down.
But neither are scams.
Before purchasing:
- Verify the retailer
- Understand your state’s shipping laws
- Question unusually low prices
- Look for real operational legitimacy
Rare bourbon should be exciting, not risky.
If you’re comparing options, take your time. Research carefully. And make sure the retailer you choose values authenticity and compliance as much as you value great whiskey.
