Eagle Rare

8 items in this collection.

What Is Eagle Rare Bourbon?

Eagle Rare is a premium bourbon whiskey produced by the iconic Buffalo Trace Distillery in Frankfort, Kentucky. Known for its smooth profile and collectability, Eagle Rare bourbon has become a staple for enthusiasts, collectors, and casual drinkers alike.

Launched in the 1970s, Eagle Rare was one of the first bourbons to be marketed as a single barrel product. Today, it continues to stand out for its consistent quality, deep flavor, and aging process that often exceeds industry standards. As part of the Buffalo Trace family, it shares lineage with other heavy-hitters like Blanton’s and Weller, yet it maintains a distinct flavor identity and reputation.

Its popularity isn’t just hype—many collectors regard Eagle Rare expressions as essential centerpieces for any serious bourbon shelf.

Eagle Rare Variants Explained

Eagle Rare offers a range of expressions that cater to varying levels of experience, preference, and budget. Here’s how each version compares:

Eagle Rare 10 Year Bourbon

Profile: Rich caramel, toffee, and hints of orange peel.

Why it’s loved: Affordable and widely available, this is often the gateway into the Eagle Rare lineup.

Eagle Rare 12 Year

Profile: Similar to the 10-year but deeper and more oak-forward.

Note: No longer in regular production, but occasionally resurfaces via select releases or private barrels.

Eagle Rare 17 Year (Antique Collection)

Profile: Bold oak, dark chocolate, dried fruits.

Distinction: Part of the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection (BTAC), this limited edition release is highly sought after.

Eagle Rare 25 Year

Profile: Layers of tobacco, spice, and deep oak.

Rarity: Ultra-premium and extremely limited—expect astronomical prices on the secondary market.

Double Eagle Very Rare

Profile: Incredibly smooth with refined sweetness and subtle spice.

Packaging: Comes in a luxurious crystal decanter and presentation box.

How Much Does Eagle Rare Cost?

Suggested Retail Prices (MSRP):

Eagle Rare 10 Year: ~$90–$100

Eagle Rare 17 Year: ~$1,900+

Eagle Rare 25 Year: ~$30,000 (limited release)

Double Eagle Very Rare: ~$4,000 (MSRP), but secondary prices can exceed $15,000

What Impacts Pricing?

Scarcity: Limited production and high demand inflate secondary market prices.

Age Statement: Older bourbons typically command premium pricing.

Awards & Hype: High-profile awards can instantly increase value and visibility.

Store & Lottery Releases: Many states allocate these via lotteries, making availability unpredictable.

Eagle Rare vs. Other Bourbons

Buffalo Trace vs. Eagle Rare:
Buffalo Trace is younger and spicier, ideal for cocktails. Eagle Rare is more nuanced and designed for sipping.

Eagle Rare vs. Blanton’s:
Blanton’s is a single-barrel bourbon with more variability. Eagle Rare tends to be more consistent in flavor.

Eagle Rare vs. Weller:
Weller bourbons are wheated, offering sweeter profiles. Eagle Rare uses rye in its mash bill, adding spice and depth.

Ideal Use Cases:

Sipping: Eagle Rare 10 and 17 are perfect neat.

Gifting: Double Eagle or 17-year are premium showpieces.

Collecting: The full vertical (10, 17, 25, Double Eagle) is a collector’s dream.

Tips for Collectors and First-Time Buyers

Spotting Fakes: Look for inconsistencies in labeling, foil wrinkling, and unusual bottle shapes. Use barcode verification apps when possible.

Storage: Store upright, in a cool, dark place. Avoid temperature swings to prevent cork degradation.

Conclusion

Eagle Rare stands tall in the world of bourbon for good reason. With expressions that range from approachable daily sippers to ultra-premium collector bottles, there’s something in the lineup for every bourbon lover.

Whether you’re buying your first bottle or adding to an established collection, Eagle Rare offers complexity, value, and status all in one pour.